Skip to main content

Noticing space: Mixed heritage experiences as a PhD student

 

"Everyday spaces are rife with diverse social dynamics, power, and subjectivity, much like Gregson and Rose suggest: ``performed spaces are not discreet, bounded spaces, but threatened, contaminated, stained, enriched by other spaces'' - Mahtani (2002) Tricking the border guards: performing race.

Back in March, I was made to feel I could not eat lunch.

We meet at 12pm in the same building we always do, we sit down in the room we do every week, with the people who typically show up, with a few new faces. 

We finish our lunches and were about to leave the room, when someone makes a comment about 'what Chinese people do'. I turn around as, I myself am Chinese, and just question what they have just said. I say "well I am Chinese and I don't do that" to assert the falseness of their general comment about the Chinese community. To visualize the room, I was stood between this white woman and a table of Chinese PhD students having lunch, with a white man right next to me. 

The white woman's response was to turn and look and point at the table of Chinese students, turns to look at the white man next to me, and looks at me to say with a slight laugh "you are not Chinese".  

I stopped in shock for a moment, but given my expertise in the topic I stood my ground and told her, you cannot tell me what my racial identity is, and that is a racial microaggression. 

She said she was "sorry I took it that way" and "didn't think I would get offended". 

She took away a safe space from me that day. 

I used to go to those lunches with joy and happiness, now I enter with a sense of distress, anxiously waiting and ready for the next student to question my identity. 

For most, this experience is nothing. Some might read this story and think it's not a big deal. But that one interaction stopped me from going to those social lunches for weeks. I was isolated. 

This is the effect a lack of race equity knowledge can have. This is what not taking an ACTIVE anti-racist stance looks like. 

All from a few comments made by one white student in an 'inclusive' space. 

I am sure many people can relate to the idea that just because you call a space 'inclusive', does not mean it is. What makes it inclusive? What are you doing to make it inclusive? What are your procedures when things like this happen? 

I tell this story with one point to make: If you are saying your spaces are inclusive, who are they inclusive for? Inclusivity in higher education usually means for white people. 

Dr Nirmal Puwar (2004) in her amazing book Space Invaders: Race, Gender, and Bodies out of Place, Puwar explains how white bodies are seen as the norm: 

"While all can, in theory, enter, it is certain types of bodies that are tactically designed as being the ‘natural’ occupants of specific positions. Some are deemed the right to belong while others are trespassers"


This table is taken from Loughborough University's Race Equality Charter, showing that on my campus from 2019-2020, there were only 27 mixed-identifying students, in comparison to the 507 white students. That's 3.2 per cent. 

It feels pretty lonely to see this number. Mixed heritage experiences are unique in many ways, but we tend to share some similar experiences when it comes to experiences of space and place on campuses. White bodies are not in the minority and therefore are seen as the 'norm', in this community we see it a lot and therefore do not question it, but we should. 

Inclusivity is not something we have, it is something we do. 

Taking an anti-racist stance is doing, not thinking. 

This is not an isolated incident, this happens to me very often, to the point where I have become used to it. This should not be the case, but it's a survival tactic I guess. This is also not just something that happens to me, but many others who are often silenced. 

To finish, I want to share with you a video campaign that is being done at the University of Exeter, to raise awareness of racial microaggressions and their effects on staff and students, which can be found here

I tell this story to make people aware of their actions, comments, and consequences

Reading this isn't going to make you an anti-racist person, reading this isn't going to make your spaces safe, reading this can start your thinking, but your actions speak for themselves. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

"Justice is not inclusion": The difference between EDI work and justice

“You can DEI your way into equality, but you cannot DEI your way into justice" I saw this quote from Dr T. Anansi Wilson @blaqueerflow on twitter the other day and it really resonated with what my friends and I discuss quite often in regards to Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion (EDI/DEI) work and justice work  You can DEI your way into equality, maybe even equity, but you cannot DEI your way into justice. Justice is not inclusion (into a violent system), but r/evolution into a new way of organising and living and dying; resources and care; power and deservability; accountability & rest.  (This is also a thread on Twitter if you would like to see more of it) What I love about this quote is that there is a difference between EDI work and justice work. Just because someone states they are committed to justice does not mean they do the work to implement what that really means. I think it’s important to distinguish in order to carry on the conversation of who is promoting activ...

Apparently, loving Britain means hating foreigners?: Far-right racism in UK EDL ‘riots’

On August 3rd, as I walked down the street I heard a shout.  "Are you a half-caste?!" they cried.  I stood in disbelief.  They continued to ask for my identity "Are you a dirty half-caste?!" As if my ambiguous face made them confused whether I was one of them or not.  Or, as if they could not decide what racial slur to call me.  Turns out, this was an EDL white supremacist.  While still used as a common phrase in many countries, in the UK it isn't typically used in common contemporary discourse.  If you don't know, as no one has really used this slur since the 50's, 'half caste'  is a derogatory term used to refer to individuals of multiracial descent to describe their 'impure' blood. White blood that has been diluted by any non-white ethnicity.  This turned my attention to the way these EDL ‘rioters’ (aka terrorists) saw race and ethnicity.   EDL racists and their perpetuation of Eugenics  EDL stands for the English Defense Le...

A ‘mixed race ‘ perspective on academic research

Picture:  @mixdgrlprblems  Instagram post  No matter where you are in the world, you will find those who connect themselves with the concept of ‘mixed race’.  It will mean different things in different places It will mean the same thing in different places  It will be mean different things in the same places  It will mean something unique to each individual person in each individual life.  For me, as a Chinese 'mixed race' woman, I identify heavily with using 'mixed race' as a linguistic home for myself. I have a Chinese mother, born in Indonesia, raised in Nigeria, and a white father born and raised in the UK. Given the erasure of a lot of our Chinese identity in the 'ethnic cleansing' in Indonesia in the 1960s, and my British cultural upbringing, it is hard to claim a Chinese identity without recognition of the white, both optically and culturally, therefore 'mixed race' works well for me. I am also 'white passing' in some spaces, giving me a d...